| Player | Season | Batters Faced |
|---|---|---|
| Hoss Radbourn (SPB) | 1 | 1399 |
| John Ward (OTT) | 1 | 1375 |
| Joe McGinnity (SPB) | 1 | 1354 |
| Joe McGinnity (ELP) | 3 | 1313 |
| Tim Keefe (VGA) | 1 | 1239 |
| Cy Young (OTT) | 1 | 1210 |
| Pete Alexander (SPB) | 4 | 1209 |
| Rube Waddell (OTT) | 3 | 1194 |
| Mickey Welch (ELP) | 4 | 1187 |
| Christy Mathewson (VGA) | 4 | 1186 |
| Walter Johnson (OTT) | 3 | 1185 |
| Chief Bender (PTL) | 4 | 1174 |
| Ed Plank (STL) | 1 | 1174 |
| Ed Walsh (NOH) | 4 | 1174 |
| Bob Gibson (GRR) | 3 | 1171 |
| Cy Young (GRR) | 2 | 1170 |
| Joe McGinnity (ELP) | 2 | 1160 |
| Mordecai Brown (NOH) | 3 | 1157 |
| Walter Johnson (OTT) | 4 | 1156 |
| Ed Walsh (NOH) | 3 | 1152 |
| Carl Mays (SPB) | 4 | 1149 |
| Pete Alexander (SPB) | 3 | 1147 |
| Juan Marichal (STL) | 4 | 1147 |
| Christy Mathewson (PTL) | 1 | 1147 |
| Ed Plank (STL) | 4 | 1146 |
| Jim Palmer (NOH) | 4 | 1143 |
| Rube Waddell (OTT) | 4 | 1140 |
| Addie Joss (STL) | 3 | 1139 |
| Pete Alexander (PTL) | 2 | 1136 |
| Chief Bender (PTL) | 3 | 1131 |